In The News

Ask Annex: Traditional IRA or Roth IRA?

Ask Annex Question

I need to fund my HAS in retirement. I’m a year away from medicare. Should I fund it from a distribution from my Traditional IRA or Roth IRA? Wouldn’t the Roth be the better choice from a tax standpoint?

-Alan

Ask Annex Answer

Alan,

The current Federal tax code allows an individual to transfer funds from their IRA to an HSA once in their lifetime.  The “rollover” is limited to the maximum annual contribution allowed into an HSA.  Assuming you have a family health insurance plan your maximum allowed contribution in 2017 is $7,750 including a $1,000 catch up provision.

You have questioned if it makes more sense to take the distribution from your Roth IRA as opposed to your traditional IRA.  We believe the best course is using your traditional IRA for two reasons:

  1. The rollover from the traditional IRA will be a tax neutral transaction meaning the IRA distribution will be taxed as ordinary income but the HSA contribution will be deductible “above the line” thus offsetting the IRA distribution income.
  2. Your Roth IRA is already growing tax free.  From a tax standpoint we would want to fund the HSA contribution with assets that would otherwise normally be subject to taxation.
We hope this has answered your question.  Let us know if we can provide further assistance.
Best regards,
Ron Johnson, CFP®
Annex Wealth Management, Financial Planning Specialist

 

 

Advisory Services offered through Annex Wealth Management®, LLC. Securities offered through H. Beck, Inc Member FINRA & SIPC. Annex Wealth Management®, LLC and H. Beck, Inc are separate and unrelated companies.

This site has been published for residents of: AZ, CA, CO, FL, IL, IN, IA, KY, MI, MN, NC, SC, TN, TX & WI ONLY. By entering you certify you are a resident of one of those states. All information herein has been prepared solely for information purposes, and it is not an offer to buy or sell, or a solicitation of an offer to buy or sell, any security.

 

/* */

<div style=”display:inline;”>
<img height=”1″ width=”1″ style=”border-style:none;” alt=”” src=”//www.googleadservices.com/pagead/conversion/940453323/?label=BOQ1CJ2Rk24Qy9u4wAM&guid=ON&script=0″/>
</div>

Read More

Axiom | Vol 502

Axiom | Vol 502

A New Fed Chair – A New Fed Policy On Fed Balance Sheet? | Money & Family: Expert Tips For Awkward Conversations | Instant Insight: Jobs & The Economic Outlook | How Do Donor Advised Funds (DAFs) Work? | When Slowing and Growing Don’t Mix | Read This Week’s Macro & Market Musings | APPLETON | Saving the Family Farm | Tuesday, February 10

read more
Axiom | Vol 502

Axiom | Vol 502

A New Fed Chair – A New Fed Policy On Fed Balance Sheet? | Quarterly Performance Reports Are Available | Estate Planning Basics | February 3 | Advanced Estate Planning | February 18 | Money & Family: Expert Tips For Awkward Conversations | How Do Donor Advised Funds (DAFs) Work? | When Slowing and Growing Don’t Mix | Read This Week’s Macro & Market Musings

read more
The 2026 Annex Asset Almanac

The 2026 Annex Asset Almanac

Almanacs are practical guides for daily life that provide information that helps you understand the way the world works. If you’re looking for help...

read more
Axiom | Vol 501

Axiom | Vol 501

A New Fed Chair – A New Fed Policy On Fed Balance Sheet? | Quarterly Performance Reports Are Available | Estate Planning Basics | February 3 | Advanced Estate Planning | February 18 | Money & Family: Expert Tips For Awkward Conversations | How Do Donor Advised Funds (DAFs) Work? | When Slowing and Growing Don’t Mix | Read This Week’s Macro & Market Musings

read more

Unleash the Power of What's Next

After decades of planning and preparation, Annex Wealth Management has established a way of doing business that promises the same warm, personal, one-on-one interaction to all clients. Using leading-edge technology, analytics and review, our staff of skilled professionals constantly seeks to confidently deliver an elite, full-service wealth management experience.

Sign Up For The Axiom®

A Look At What’s Happening
From Annex Wealth Management

Name